Is It Almost Time For Josh Johnson To Go? :: Marlins Daily – A Miami Marlins Blog
Jan
11

Is It Almost Time For Josh Johnson To Go?

By

Let me start off my saying that my name is Ryan Gaydos and I am one of the newest bloggers here at Marlins Daily. I will do my best to bring you the best Miami Marlins coverage out there. I am very thankful to be given this new position at Marlins Daily.

Now with all the introductions out of the way, let’s get to some Marlins talk starting with the ace of the new-look rotation, Josh Johnson. Johnson has been known in recent years for holding the Marlins rotation together and yet also being the most injury prone of the rotation. We have all seen him at his best when he’s healthy.

When Johnson is unhealthy, it seems like the rest of the rotation rots and no one feels like stepping up until the end of the season. The Marlins saw that when Javier Vazquez who finished 13-11 and won his last six decisions consecutively.

Last season, Josh Johnson was on a hot streak. He was 3-1 with a 1.67 ERA and was one of the hottest pitchers in the league. Then Johnson was sidelined with shoulder inflammation and was never seen from again. Johnson was moved from the 15-day disabled list to the 60-day disabled list in June and after that there was no hope left.

The only good news received about Josh Johnson last season when he was inevitably finished for the year was that he would not have to undergo Tommy John surgery. You could literally hear the sigh of relief coming from Florida when that bit of information was announced. Now, Johnson will be throwing off a mound within two weeks according to Joe Capozzi of the Palm Beach Post.

With the threat of Johnson being injury looming every year, maybe it should be time that the new, radical Miami Marlins do something that is, well, radical. That something would be looking to trade Johnson for some younger pitching or maybe a pitcher that is less prone to injuries than Johnson is.

There is no time to panic in Miami because the 2012 season has not even started yet. When Johnson is healthy, he is great and that is something that should be a selling point for the Marlins if they do indeed try to trade Johnson in the near future. In the past five seasons, Johnson is 36-16 in 88 games pitched. Those totals seem impressive but in those five seasons he has only managed to pitch over 25 games twice due to injuries.

Another bad part of trading Johnson is that he is signed to the Marlins until 2013 and will be owed $13.7 million this year and the next.

The idea of Johnson possibly being traded probably does not sit well with some Marlins fans. But maybe he could be used to attract younger talent in Miami so that the Marlins could start building a possible foundation for the future beyond the likes of Hanley Ramirez, Jose Reyes and Mark Buehrle.

Should the Miami Marlins trade Josh Johnson? What do you think?

Follow Ryan Gaydos on Twitter @RyanGaydos

Categories : Baseball Talk
  • Haleck75

    I know this is your first post, and I don’t like overly-critical blogs, but I have to say that this is a crazy idea. JJ could very well be our ace for the next decade. You just don’t replace guys like him. You just hope he stays healthy and move along.

    • http://mlbdirt.com/ Jonathan C. Mitchell

      I agree you have to hold onto JJ here. The Marlins, apparently, have money and trading JJ right now, while trying to contend in their first season in the new ballpark, would be a bad idea.

    • Ryan Gaydos

      The thing is, what if he doesn’t stay healthy. His health is inconsistent. Are the Marlins willing to pay a guy the big bucks to sit out most of the season? We’ll see, I guess..

  • jlr04

    This is a joke right? i suggest you never, ever again think up any trade ideas, thank you.

    • Ryan Gaydos

      A little overly critical..

  • Matt

    Trading JJ isn’t a terrible idea, but I would NEVER look to trade a top 5 pitcher (when healthy). Every player should be “on the block” if the right offer is presented, but let the offers present themselves to the Marlins rather than shop this guy. As for your point about no other pitcher looking to “step up”, that should be taken care of now that the Marlins brought in more depth at pitcher with Buehrle who has been the Ace of the Sox for a decade it seems like. My fix for the JJ Russian Roulette game we play each year would be to wait until the first couple months and let HanRam show that he is still elite, and send him to Seattle for King Felix (I understand the chances are 1% that this happens, but a guy can dream).

  • ecp

    You do realize that shoulder inflammation NEVER results in Tommy John surgery – which is on the elbow – don’t you?

  • JWO

    Respectfully, your analysis is a bit empty. You made a couple of safe statements: Johnson is an ace when healthy; Johnson is frequently injured; and the Marlins are in an aggressive stance this year. but you didn’t present any new or intriguing ideas.

    What clubs might be interested in a Josh Johnson trade, given his injury history? What would the Marlins be looking for in terms of a return? I was looking for some substance, but I think all you’ve done is throw out a hypothetical. Still, practice makes perfect. Welcome aboard, and lets hope we get an interesting season from the fish…

  • Fishfan

    You can’t be for real.
    JJ is THE face of the Marlins pitching rotation.

    And there are VERY few starters in the NL or even AL who’d be an upgrade. (?Carp ?Cliff Lee ?CC… Any idea of the $100Ms it would take to make THAT deal happen?)

    And let’s be realistic…until there starts to LOTS of sell outs at the new park (StubHub ain’t looking too pretty yet), Loria’s probably spent about as much on big name acquisitions (MB, JR, HB) as they can financially afford to do at this point.

    Only other viable option if Big Z melts down (Ozzie’s job to keep him relaxed) is for Ozzie to go to PR and BEG Javy to come back from retirement.